Imagine, you’re considering buying a shed for your backyard and you’re faced with the common question: plastic or wood? In this article, we will unravel the benefits and drawbacks of both, helping you to make an informed choice that best suits your needs. This is a comprehensive exploration and comparison of plastic and wooden sheds, sharing insights on what they can offer in terms of durability, maintenance, and aesthetic appeal.
Overview of Plastic and Wood Sheds
Sheds are versatile and practical additions to any property. Available in varying types of materials, including plastic and wood, the choice between them often boils down to personal preference, need, and environmental conditions.
Material composition and features
Plastic sheds, typically made of resin or vinyl, are lightweight, easy to assemble, and require minimal maintenance. Resistant to rot, insects, and weather-induced degradation, they offer a hassle-free solution for storage.
Wooden sheds, on the other hand, provide a timeless, rustic appeal. From softwoods like pine and cedar to hardwoods like oak, wood sheds are strong, sturdy, and offer excellent insulation. However, they require regular maintenance to prevent rot and pest-infestation.
Common types and designs
Plastic sheds, due to their moldable nature, are available in a plethora of designs and sizes, ranging from compact lean-tos to expansive barn-style structures.
Wooden sheds also come in various designs, such as traditional apex, reverse apex and the modern pent style. The design for wooden sheds can be very intricate, especially with additional features like porches and windows.
History and evolution of sheds
Sheds have a rich history, with their utility and design evolving over time. Initially, they were just simple wood structures. However, with the advent of industrialization, alternative materials like metal and plastic were introduced. The introduction of plastic sheds in the late 20th century was a game-changer with their easy assembly, low maintenance, and cheaper price points.
Durability and Longevity
Shedography.com
Life expectancy of plastic sheds versus wood sheds
While both plastic and wood sheds offer different advantages, their life expectancy is contingent on factors like the quality of material, and local weather conditions. Plastic sheds can usually last upwards of 10 years, with higher-end models going upto 25 years.
Wood sheds, if maintained properly, can last for several decades. However, they require treatments to protect them from insects and the elements.
Effects of weather on both materials
Plastic sheds exhibit impressive resilience to weather conditions. They are unaffected by rain, snow, and sunlight. However, they can become brittle in cold weather and warp with extreme heat.
Wood sheds, although sturdy, are susceptible to humidity causing rot and water damage, while too much sun can lead to warping or cracking.
Mitigating long term wear and tear
The lifespan of both plastic and wood sheds can be extended with regular maintenance. While plastic sheds just require an annual clean, wooden sheds need treatments every few years to protect against rot and insects.
Maintenance and Upkeep
Cleaning requirements
Cleaning a plastic shed is a simple task – a quick hosing down with soapy water will do the trick.
For a wooden shed, a thorough annual clean with a wood cleaning solution is recommended to prevent mold and mildew.
Repair possibilities and complexity
Repairs on plastic sheds can be tricky as you can’t replace just one panel or piece. However, these sheds are quite durable and less likely to need repairs.
Wooden sheds are easier to repair, as individual boards can be replaced. Yet they are more prone to requiring fixes due to their susceptibility to rot and bugs.
Need for regular treatments or paints
Unlike wooden sheds, plastic sheds do not require any painting or treatments, which is one less chore to think about.
On the other hand, wooden sheds need regular treatment to keep the pests and dampness at bay. Plus, they may also need periodic repainting.
Aesthetic Appeal and Customization
Flexibility in design and color for plastic sheds
Thanks to the manufacturing process, plastic sheds have a wide range of designs and colors. However, once chosen, you are stuck with the design and color.
Wood’s natural appeal and customization capabilities
A wooden shed has an undeniable classic appeal. Plus, they can be easily tailored to match your home or garden aesthetic with just a splash of paint or varnish.
Suitability for different settings and landscapes
Plastic sheds, with their sleek modern designs, work well in contemporary settings.
Wooden sheds blend seamlessly into natural and rustic landscapes.
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
Comparative environmental footprint
Plastic sheds have a higher carbon footprint due to the manufacturing process.
Wooden sheds, made from a renewable resource, generally have a smaller carbon footprint, especially if the wood is sourced locally and responsibly.
Recycling and waste management aspects
At the end of their life, high-quality plastic sheds are fully recyclable. However, not all plastic sheds meet this standard.
Wooden sheds can be responsibly disposed of or even repurposed.
Use of sustainable sources and materials
In the case of wooden sheds, it’s important to check that the timber has been responsibly sourced, ideally bearing a sustainability certification.
Plastic sheds are not typically made from recyclable material, although there is a growing trend towards this.
Safety and Fire Resistance
Fire safety properties of plastic and wood sheds
Neither material is fireproof, but plastic sheds tend to be more resistant to catching fire than untreated wood.
Potential hazards and risks
Both materials have their risks. Plastic sheds can release toxic fumes if they catch fire, while wooden sheds can be a fire hazard if not treated with a fire retardant.
Precautions and mitigations
It’s recommended to keep flammable materials securely stored and out of reach, and install a fire alarm in both types of sheds.
Thermal Properties and Insulation
Effect of material on temperature inside the shed
Plastic sheds can become distressingly hot in summer and chilly in winter. On the other hand, wooden sheds have excellent insulating properties.
Insulation properties of plastic and wood
Wood is a better insulator than plastic, thanks to its cellular structure.
Need for additional insulation or cooling
Regardless of the shed material, if you plan on using the shed year-round, additional insulation or a ventilation fan can be beneficial.
Cost and Value for Money
Initial cost comparison
Plastic sheds are generally more affordable than wooden sheds, making them a budget-friendly choice.
Ongoing maintenance costs
Although more expensive upfront, wooden sheds can prove cost-efficient if properly maintained.
Long-term value for investment
When considering the durability, aesthetic appeal, and the environmental impact, purchasing quality sheds of either material can be a sound long-term investment.
Build and Installation
Ease of assembling plastic sheds
Plastic sheds are lightweight and easy to assemble, often clicking together in a modular way.
Construction complexity of wood sheds
Wooden sheds, while more complex, offer a rewarding DIY project for those with carpentry skills. Otherwise, professional installation may be beneficial.
Availability of professional installation services
While both types of sheds can be installed with professional help, companies often offer installation services at an additional cost.
Conclusion and Recommendation
Summarisation of key points
In summary, whether you choose a plastic or wood shed depends on your individual needs, lifestyle, and personal tastes.
Contextual recommendation based on user need
For ease of maintenance and cost-effectiveness, a plastic shed could be your best bet. However, if aesthetics, insulation, and a natural look are a priority, a wooden shed would be more suitable.
Call for personal preference and customisation scope
Ultimately, the choice is yours. Both plastic and wood sheds have their advantages and setbacks. Consider your specific needs, preferences, and the shed’s purpose before making your decision.